Showing posts with label Mobile. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mobile. Show all posts

Saturday, December 1, 2012

Image problems with self-published books on the Nook HD


This week I was able to try out the Nook HD for the first time. It's a sharp little e-reader that I would buy in a second if I had the extra cash. It's lighter than the iPad, has a nice form factor, has a far superior UX to the Kindle, and handles video and even gaming graphics quite well. When you open an ebook on the Nook HD, the pages look crisp and have a nice off-white background. But I observed a problem with the way the Nook HD renders images on self-published books.

I observed the problem in one of my own books, a basic Excel manual that I published earlier this year. The images, which were intended to have full-screen widths, were reduced to about 50% of the page width. This made details impossible to read. Of course, it's possible to "blow up" the image by tapping on them, but that ruins the reading flow and also takes time (there are about 100 screenshots in this guide).

I don't have Nook HD screenshots to share, but I'll try to illustrate the problem with some facts and a sample image from the book that was made unreadable. The Nook HD has 1440 x 900 pixel resolution with 243 pixels per inch. This means an image that's half the width of the screen (450px) will be 1.85 inches wide. Here's what a 1.85 inch wide image from my book looks like in a browser (96 ppi):

Nook HD image problem

Do you see the problem?

The file format used by the Nook is an ebook publishing standard known as ePub. Apple's iOS devices use the same ePub files as the Nook. When I was working on Excel Basics In 30 Minutes, I tested the ePub file extensively in the e-reader that I own (an iPad2) as well as in the Nook simulator provided by Barnes & Noble's Pubit service. It looked great in the iPad. On the Nook HD simulator, the images were actually too large for the screen -- Pubit actually warns authors that images may appear strange. I assumed that they would be resized to fit the Book HD screen. Little did I know that they would be reduced to the point of being unreadable.

Any other authors experiencing this problem with their Nook titles?

Saturday, September 8, 2012

Another faked sequence in a phone ad. Is anyone surprised?

The clever folks at The Verge caught Nokia trying to pass off a whopper on its ads for the new Lumia phone. The ad, which promotes the phone's supposed image stabilization features, is short, and The Verge helpfully points out the fakery:



This phone, incidentally, is supposed to save Nokia (and Windows Mobile) from iPhone/Android. It doesn't look too good for Nokia if the technology is being faked.

But hold on. Do users really even care? After seeing so many faked-video-on-mobile-phone ads over the past 10 years, I think most people have been conditioned to lower their expectations because the reality is never as smooth, fast, or crisp as the ads would like us to believe. Verizon Droid ads and some of the Korean manufacturers are especially guilty of exaggerated simulations, but even Apple has been known to lie in its ads.

Tuesday, June 19, 2012

Craigslist beta-testing mobile version of site



Spotted on a Craigslist discussion forum today: A note from a Craigslist staffer that the San Francisco company is beta-testing new versions of the site that work on mobile devices and tablets. It's not an app, but rather an HTML version of the classifieds service that's optimized for smartphone and tablet browsers.

I gave the Craigslist mobile beta a spin on an iPod touch, an iPad2, and my Android device (Samsung Exhibit II) and was impressed with a few features. However, some elements still need work.

Craigslist on an iPod/iPhone

When you first arrive at your local Craigslist area using an iPod (or iPhone), this is what you see: 



Posting: The UX seems to mirror the steps taken on the desktop browser version of Craigslist: 





















An index view. The big improvement here is the ability to see thumbnails, along with the price. You can also expand the ad to see a bigger picture, right in the middle of the list. However, I noticed the amount of content shown on the screen was less than what could be seen in the Android version (see below) :






















Android smartphone, index view. Note more titles are visible than on the iPhone/iPod rendition:






















iPad screenshots


The main arrival screen:





















The tablet index view looks optimized for smaller devices:






















Previewing an ad on a tablet:






















You can see the mobile/tablet beta yourself by going to craigslist.org on your mobile device and looking for the faint links to the mobile and tablet versions at the bottom of the page.

Friday, February 24, 2012

Getting close to launching our app

We're getting close to launching the Invantory app for iOS mobile devices. What does the app do? Well, the first iteration is aimed at making it easy for people to buy on Craigslist with an iPhone or iPad. Here's a screenshot of what a classifieds listing looks like:

guitar classifieds

This looks a lot different than what you typically see on the PC/Web version of Craigslist. In addition, the experience of browsing listings on a mobile device using Invantory is really unique. Instead of looking at text lists and using search engines, the focus is on photos. This helps people quickly determine what is of interest, and also helps them evaluate quality.

Future versions of the Invantory Craigslist app will do lots of other things, including creating classifieds and distributing the listings elsewhere.

Has it been tough building an app? For my partner Sam, it has been extremely time-consuming, with many technical hurdles to overcome. Are we nervous about the launch? Absolutely. Are there ups and downs associated with running a startup? Every week I am on a startup roller coaster. But nevertheless we are making progress and are really looking forward to what matters: Whether or not people will like using the app. We hope you can try the app and let us know. Download the app via the Invantory website, or sign up to be notified by email when it launches.

Friday, November 25, 2011

TMobile monthly 4G + Samsung Exhibit II = Android on the cheap


I'm one of those cell phone cheapskates. You know, the guy who didn't own a mobile phone until it was absolutely necessary, and then only got the cheapest phone/plan options possible -- or got it through his employer. For the past few years, I have been using AT&T GoPhone/Pay-As-You-Go plans and the cheapo Nokia feature phones that come with them. A few weeks ago, however, I joined the elite, getting a snazzy Android phone (Samsung Exhibit II) and a really reasonable carrier plan -- the $30 TMobile Monthly 4G plan -- through Walmart. I'll give a quick review of the phone and the T-Mobile plan below.


First, a relevant fact to this review is that while I have been a cellphone cheapskate for a decade, I am actually a pretty heavy iOS user. I don't own an iPhone, but we have an iPad at home as well as two iPod touch devices. The newer one (4th generation) has been something that never leaves my side -- I use it for email, photos, twitter, Instagram, the Weather Channel app, music, and about a dozen other regular uses (I have wi-fi at home and work, which enables a pretty good mobile experience at these locations). If I had the funds to afford an $80 or $90 monthly iPhone plan through AT&T or Verizon, I would have gotten an iPhone, but I don't. But my work as co-founder of Invantory (a company that is developing a Craigslist app) was getting more intense and requires more frequent calling. This forced me to get a new phone plan with more capacity.

I began hearing about the TMobile Monthly4G plan in October, offered through Wal-Mart. It sounded great -- the cheapest option cost $30 per month, included unlimited texting and Web (first 5G at 4G speeds, 2G thereafter) and 100 minutes of talk, with 10 cents per minute thereafter.

This worked out to be far better than the AT&T GoPhone plan, which costs $25 for 100 minutes of talk and charges 25 cents for additional minutes. AT&T texting is 20 cents and data is similarly expensive and practically unusable on the tiny Nokia browser and terrible e-mail interface. Virgin reportedly had a similar plan to T-Mobile, but it was $5 more per month.

T-Mobile/WalMart offered a bunch of different phones, but I was really set on Android -- it was an iPhone-like experience and will eventually become a platform for Invantory's mobile classifieds. T-Mobile had an Android phone called the Samsung Dart, but it had poor reviews (including poor voice quality). The Samsung Exhibit II, however, sounded much better, and worked with the new monthly4G plan.

The plan had just been launched, so I began visiting local Wal-marts to look for the phone and try it out. It was useless. The boxed phones for the Tmobile Monthly 4G plan were there, but they were feature phones and the Dart. The Exhibit II wasn't in stock, and staff had no idea what I was talking about (even in a store which the Walmart website listed as having it "in stock"). The phone was also supposed to be available through T-Mobile stores, but at a 25% markup ($250 vs $200 in Walmart). I eventually gave up seeing the phone in person and just ordered it online through Walmart.com.

Out of the box, the phone worked well, but there were some hiccups. Here's the low down:

Activation and voice service
  • Activation via live T-Mobile customer service is a problem if you want the $30 plan -- for some reason the reps only have another $30 plan (1500 talk and text, see screenshot below) and will direct you to register online if you want the 100 minutes talk/unlimited Web & text.
  • It didn't seem to be a problem to get a phone number in my area code (I mention this because a long time ago it used to be an issue with new mobile phones, or you'd be assigned a phone in the 857 area code)
  • Even though T-Mobile apparently charges minutes against some plan users who make calls on their Wifi signals. "Wifi Calling" is not counted against the Monthly4G plan minutes -- I talked with a customer service representative to confirm this. After conducting a test, I determined that Wifi Calling is counted against your minutes, and another T-Mobile rep confirmed this (contradicting what the first one said). Therefore, I advise turning off Wifi calling and putting the load on the T-Mobile network. You're paying for it either way, might as well make T-Mobile work for it and reconsider their policy. 
  • The Samsung Exhibit II has a excellent voice quality, and I have yet to have a dropped call.
  • 4G coverage seems reasonably good in and around the Boston area, even on some subway lines (MBTA Red Line, but not the Green Line)
Exhibit II hardware
  • The Exhibit II is a very lightweight phone that has a somewhat slippery plastic case -- it will easily fall out of loose pockets when you are sitting down.
  • The processor is adequate, but I have noticed that sometimes it hangs (especially if you are awakening it from sleep with an app already open).
  • Storage is paltry compared to my 4th-generation iPod touch -- USB storage is listed as 1.6 GB, and device memory >800 MB. It's not a problem for people who don't have a lot of media on their phones, but if you are a heavy music, photo, or video user you will have to get an SD card.
  • The battery seems to charge fast. However, I generally have to charge it once every 36 hours 15 hours, leaving it on all the time with relatively low voice usage and high "other" usage (surfing, camera, apps, email, etc.). Update: Battery life seems to be getting worse as time goes on. Part of this relates to the fact that I am using more apps and talking more often on it, but it seems the decline is excessive, even though I am shutting off GPS and often disabling Wifi (note: Disabling wifi apparently increases battery usage, owing to the fact that the device is constantly searching for 4G signals. I've found the best tactic is to leave wifi on all day). The batteries in my iPod touches are far more resilient after many thousands of hours of heavy wifi, app, and camera use.
  • Screen quality: Excellent! At 480 x 800, the dimensions are slimmer than the iPod touch (640 x 960 pixels), but the resolution seems comparable.
  • Photo syncing via USB doesn't work with my two-year-old iMac and iPhoto. But sharing to Dropbox from photo app on the Exhibit II partially makes up for that problem.
  • The Wifi receiver is adequate, with slightly less range than the iPod touch. Switching between Wifi/Edge/3G/4G happens in the background and works well.
Camera

This is probably my biggest beef with the phone. Here are the pros and cons:
  • The resolution of both the front-facing and rear-facing cameras are acceptable and superior to my 4th generation iTouch. 
  • The flash works very well in low-light settings. 
  • But the lag for shooting is sometimes as long as two seconds, which makes setting up shots of people and moving objects difficult and irritating. Auto-focus is apparently to blame, and it can't be turned off (although you can switch to a pretty nice macro setting). 
  • There is no "camera+" or Instagram app for the phone, which is a big negative for someone coming from the iOS universe.
  • The other problem is color -- reds and oranges are definitely muted, as you may be able to see from the photo below. The wood floor actually has a richer color, and the red and yellow legos are a very bright, child-friendly color in reality (the reds below should be fire-engine red, but they're not). The blues, meanwhile, are too strong -- in this photo the detail on the blue boxes can't be seen from afar because the color is so intense.

Samsung Exhibit II test

Android Software
  • Once you get used to Android (my Exhibit II came installed with Android 2.3.5 "Gingerbread") it's a wonderful platform. But getting used to some of the quirks takes time. There are other negatives, too, which I will detail first.
  • "Settings", "My Accounts" and "Accounts and Sync" and individual app settings contain overlapping information and controls. It can be hard to find what you are looking for, and difficult to do certain things such as turning off notification sounds (although there is a "Sound Settings" option, it does not control all sound settings -- you'll have to root around in various apps to turn everything off). 
  • For other settings, I still haven't figured out to adjust them -- such as turning off or changing the startup/power down sounds. How do you turn off the "recharged" sound, so it doesn't wake you up in the middle of the night? I have no idea. iOS is far superior, centralizing all system settings and many app settings in a single place ("Settings"), and making it very easy to disable all sounds.
  • To get carriers to adopt Android, Google made the operating system customizable to a certain extent. The result: Most American carriers, including T-Mobile, load up their phones with crapware which apparently can't be deleted. I got T-Mobile TV HD, T-Mobile Mall, Kies Air, Blio, Yelp, an antivirus program, "Bonus Apps", and bunch of other stuff I didn't want and cluttered up my screens. As it is apparently impossible or difficult to delete them, I had to create a special screen to hold them. Apple forces carriers to stay away from the crapware  practice and allows people to easily delete apps and files, which makes iOS far superior for new users. 
  • Android confusingly has separate "Home" and "Apps" screens, both of which can be customized. iOS only has one view, and allows you to place files and Web bookmarks on it, giving it the same prominence as apps.  
  • Apps: Android does not win on quality (as a more open system, there are a lot of crappy apps out there) but the process of downloading, installing, and trying out the apps is much faster -- no need to enter an iTunes password each time or hunt for the app once it's installed. I installed lots of apps, including Dropbox, Instagram and Google Docs for Android (explained in detail in this Google Docs for Dummies clone)
  • Email: Android's default email app looks better and seems to work faster than iOS on wifi. My only complaint is "mark as unread" is not available (it is, however, an option in the Android Gmail app). 
  • Sync: I've always felt that iOS syncing (and now iCloud) is imperfect. I'll set stuff up, such as Google calendar, and it doesn't seem to get imported into my iPod's Calendar app. But Android really rocks -- you can even attach and group Facebook and twitter accounts, which makes for a better Contacts list. 
  • Customization: If you can find the right options, you can do some pretty neat things, such as setting up live wallpapers that move (a swirling galaxy is one of the defaults). iOS will surely catch up, though.
  • Keyboard and voice input: The Android keyboard is not as good as the one on iOS devices. This is partially the result of the Exhibit's narrower screen, but I also find myself having to "aim" a little high to press the right character. On the other hand, voice input integrated into the keyboard is superb. Just press the microphone on the keyboard (or next to the search magnifying glass), speak clearly, and you'll see it entered. It may not compare to Siri, but considering Siri is not available on most iPhones or any iPods, I'd say Android has the upper hand at the low end of the market.

I may have some other updates as time goes on and I use the phone more. But so far, so good.



Screenshot: Current TMobile Monthly 4G rates:

Tmobile monthly 4g plan rate sheet

Wednesday, October 5, 2011

Steve Jobs' star

Yesterday I was thinking about Steve Jobs, and the fact that he wasn't even mentioned at yesterday's iPhone event in Cupertino. Now we know why.

People who knew him will be able to eulogize his passing better than I can, but I did want to say that he has touched my life since the earliest days I was involved in computing. At my middle school in the early 80s, we had a computer room set up with Apple II+ and Apple IIe computers. It was on those machines that I first began to learn how to program, which set up a life-long affair with hardware, software and digital media that continues to this day.

It didn't stop with that early Apple experience. Eight years ago I got back into Apple's products through my "half dome" iMac on which I spent many late nights running remote database queries and writing a graduate thesis. An early iPod classic provided the soundtrack to my morning and evening commutes, and more recently I have treasured my iPod touch, which has really let me improve my life and connect with people in ways that I never could have imagined just a decade ago. With this remarkable little device, I was even able to take a two-week international trip without lugging along a laptop, as I have done during earlier overseas trips. The iTouch handled email, news, gaming, utilities, photos, twitter, Facebook, and even Skype. It was on this trip that I realized that we really are transitioning to a post-PC world, and Steve Jobs is directly responsible.

Last month I attended the dedication of Steve's star on the Entrepreneur Walk of Fame in Kendall Square, not far from MIT's campus. Journalist Dan Lyons (who famously created the parody blog "Fake Steve Jobs")  came up to the podium to give a short dedication. The MIT Entrepreneur Center's Bill Aulet noted Lyons was reluctant to do so, as Steve was known to be in grave health. Lyons spoke to the small crowd, remarking that while Jobs had stepped down from running the company, he insisted on remaining as chairman of the board.  "Even now, in his very poor, slipping health, he can not let go of Apple," Lyons said. "He has literally given his life to his vision." Lyons added that Jobs was unafraid to have his company cannibalize its own products, in the name of progress and creating great things.

I'd like to end this post with the engraving from Jobs' star in Cambridge. It reads:
"Being the richest man in the cemetery doesn't matter to me ... Going to bed at night, saying we've done something wonderful... that's what matters to me."
RIP, Steve.

Wednesday, June 8, 2011

Data visualizations: Why most will never make it in the marketplace


Eric Hill, a buddy of mine from my old Industry Standard days, sent me a link to a RWW article about a cool new iPad application from Bloom Studio that comes up with an interesting way of visualizing a digital music collection. The app is called Planetary, and here's what it looks like:


Planetary (voiceover) from Bloom Studio, Inc. on Vimeo.

I was impressed with what they've done, but I am afraid it won't go far in the marketplace. At one time I had so much hope for data visualizations changing the way we browse and understand information -- in fact, Eric and I spent a lot of time discussing how Industry Standard site content (news and prediction market data) could be presented in new and potentially useful ways. But in the past several years, after checking out dozens of new interfaces and data visualization schemes, I've come to the conclusion that most will never catch on.


It's not the fault of the designers, but rather the limitations of audiences. For many consumers, simple formats (e.g., longitudinal line graphs, like the inset image of the US$/Euro exchange rate over the past three months) and plain ol' headlines are all they need. I think part of the problem is grokking a new visualization requires new mental models. In my opinion, most people simply aren't willing to expend the effort, especially considering the huge amounts of information out there and limited time that people have to consume it. I've seen so many interesting, creative visualizations out there but most never make it in the marketplace. Planetary is cool, but is a solar system/galactic metaphor for browsing music inherently better than an alphabetically ordered list of artists/albums/songs?

See also:

Friday, December 31, 2010

How fast is the social Web growing?

Wicked. Darn. Fast.

Play around with the tool below. Click on the one-day option, to see how much has been spent on virtual goods, or how many YouTube videos have been watched. The numbers are astounding. Check out the other tabs, too, for mobile and gaming. 3.4 million new mobile phones shipped and 16.4 billion SMSs since yesterday? 16 million WoW quests played in the same time period?

Now we know why Verizon and other carriers charge so much for data!



Link: John Bothwick

Sunday, October 31, 2010

iPod touch video recording: A lesson for broadcast news?

The Newslab blog recently posted about the differences between "professional" video shot with TV crews and video created with mobile devices. Judging by the tone of the article, CNN and others are experimenting with such tools, but are doing so in a very cautious manner. It prompted me to leave a comment, in which I said:
I recently started using a 4th generation iPod touch (I bought the 32GB model on Amazon for $280), which has a decent video camera built in, to shoot simple clips/interviews. [This] blog post demonstrates what I was able to produce:



Note that the only editing I did on the interview consisted of trimming the ends off the clip, an ability which is included in the iPod's camera application. From within the app, I uploaded it to YouTube, and then switched to my laptop to embed the YouTube clip on my blog post. A few days ago, I bought a $4 app in Apple's mobile app store called "ReelDirector" that lets me mix clips, add titles, switch transitions, and even add music.

With the cheap price and high level of functionality on these devices, there's no excuse for trying out mobile video. Is it pro quality? Of course not. But it's certainly enough to do newsgathering and interviews on the fly. And, the gear fits in your pocket and can be operated by the journalist -- no need for expensive cameras, extra crew, and extra overhead to get the story out.

It's apparent that there is still a lot of resistance in the broadcast news industry to using cheap mobile devices, laptop cameras, as well as any production process that's not "pro." In the mid-1990s, I worked in a TV newsroom, and know the prevailing attitude among many broadcast journalists (and crews) is a near obsession over making sure only the best-looking people and best-looking footage appear on screen. At the time, our reporter/cameraman teams would spend three or four hours every morning shooting tape and setting up interviews, and the remainder of the day editing down the footage and doing voice-overs. The result? One or two 2-minute clips per team per day.

Long after I had transitioned to online, the Flip video camera came out, and was a hit. Until the Flip, consumer video cameras from Sony and JVC tended to have complicated user interfaces designed by Japanese engineers. The Flip did away with 90% of the UI clutter, and had just five buttons, a flash drive to store 60 minutes of video, and a flip-out USB plug to transfer video files to PCs. It was also very cheap -- just $125 dollars. I enthusiastically began using one for reviews and interviews, and evangelized it to everyone in the Computerworld newsroom. This was in 2007. However, the weak point with the Flip was the lack of good editing software, which forced us to turn to professional video staff for more complex editing tasks. Never mind the information or images captured by the Flip -- there was more than a little skepticism from the pro video people about the jerky, poorly lit footage, tinny audio, and the fact that there were compatibility issues with the expensive AVID editing suites they used.

Now, the Flip looks positively ancient compared to the iPod touch with its simple editing tools and wireless uploading. The iPhone and the iTouch have the potential to turn many online text-based journalists -- and even people who have never worked in a newsroom or been trained as journalists -- into effective online video journalists.

The professional broadcast community may not get it right now, but they will get the message soon enough when lots of quality work is performed by jackknife journalists and amateur producers, and audiences make it clear that expensive modes of production are not a prerequisite for their attention.

Sunday, July 25, 2010

Supply and demand for online news


A few weeks ago I discussed how long-form journalism was a poor fit for mobile devices. In addition, long-form content such as features is increasingly tough to use on the Web, where information/entertainment distractions are never farther than a hyperlink, bookmark, or tweet away.

But Frédéric Filloux's excellent Monday Note brings up another factor that's going against lengthy essays, features, and videos: A shift in consumption habits among young Web users (Digital Natives) who have grown up with the technologies. He writes:
"... The fastest is the best. Forget about long form journalism. Quick TV newscasts, free commuter newspapers, bursts of news bulletins on the radio are more than enough. The group will do the rest: it will organize the importance, the hierarchy of news elements, it will set the news cycle’s pace."
The "group" is the trusted social circle which serves as an echo chamber and information channel. Trust is vitally important to this group, Filloux writes, and most corporate media doesn't have it.

The other essay that is worth a quick scan is Jeff Jarvis' analysis (via Mediagazer) of the recent Conde Nast corporate shakeup and the company's admission that advertising cannot be counted on to support operations (I wonder how much they paid McKinsey for that piece of advice?). As for Conde Nast's plan to recoup revenue through high-priced online subscriptions, Jarvis' incredulous reaction nails it:
The problem is going to be that there is only *more* competition in content and so trying to suddenly charge *more* flies in the face of basic economics. The absurdity of the strategy struck me yesterday as Amazon tried to sell me a subscription to Time for 28.8 cents an issue while Time is trying to sell its iPad issues for $4.99 and I see no reason to buy either. In what world do these economics make sense?
I agree with Jarvis (I had a similar reaction to Conde Nast's "How about a buck a click" quote when I saw it), but wouldn't it be interesting to do a back-of-the-napkin supply/demand curve to model what's going on with online information and plans to charge for it? I'm pretty sure the demand curve would show a small number of people who don't care about price and will gladly register for paid news or download an expensive mobile news app; a large (but not huge) population who won't pay much and are extremely sensitive to price increases; and then the majority of the population who won't pay anything. If plotted, it would look something like this:
"P" represents price on the Y axis, and "Q" represents quantity on the X axis. Both lines continue off the page. In my microeconomics class, demand levels were depicted as being linear or slightly concave. But for online news, I believe demand at high price levels is very low, and rapidly drops as the price increases (iPad news app developers, take note!). It flattens out as prices approach zero, but that shouldn't be much consolation for providers. The price level is too low to support operations unless there is a massive audience, but Q hits $0 much too soon -- there's simply too much free news out there, plus many other free or low-cost alternatives (see "Quality vs. junk journalism"? Or news vs. other information/distractions?), meaning that the Q value for paid news will always be low.

What's missing from this chart? The supply curve. Typically, it runs perpendicular to demand, starting near the origin of the graph (where x and y intersect) and moving up and to the right in a more or less straight fashion, reflecting the fact that as prices increase, more Q (i.e., more supply) will be made available to sell and consume.

But for paid news, I can't quite figure out how to draw it. Any product in a capitalist economy should follow the basic supply curve pattern described in the previous paragraph. But in the online news industry, publishers are making so much content -- including high-quality content -- available for free. How do you draw that? (Economists or readers with a better understanding of how the theory works in situations like this, please feel free to weigh in below, in the comments section)

In some cases, publishers are offering content for free on some platforms, while attempting to charge for it on others. Conde Nast's Wired is a perfect example: Conde Nast has $10-$12 annual subscriptions, which are sometimes issued for free (I pay nothing now -- is my zip code that good?), or you can pay the $5 newsstand price. Wired's paid and verified circulation is 754,574, according to the Conde Nast media kit. Or, you can read most content online for free. Quantcast reports more than two million people do that every month. Then you have the Wired iPad app, which launched with lots of fanfare earlier this year at $5 an issue, but was almost immediately discounted the following month. The total number of June iPad issues sold the first month? 95,000. If you plot the online/digital users on the demand curve, it would look something like this:
Theoretically, supply and prices should dial down to meet demand and reach a state of equilibrium. I don't see how this can happen for paid online news, as long as there is an open system of information exchange that allows for a constantly growing mass of content of all types, most of it free. There may be some exceptions in niche topics such as finance. But news, commentary, and analysis in most other fields is rapidly becoming a commodity in a sea of information alternatives. Add to that factors such as the consumption patterns cited by Filloux, and a never-ending stream of new platforms and information products, which fragments the audience even further. In such an environment, the prospects for getting people to pay for news are very limited.

Tuesday, July 13, 2010

E-readers won't save journalism

For some time, I've been wanting to write more about online news organizations and the competitive environment they now find themselves in. I was finally prompted to do so after reading an essay about e-readers by the Columbia Journalism Review's Curtis Brainard (linked from Mediagazer). Judging by its length and lack of a search engine-friendly title ("A Second Chance") it's clearly intended for a print audience. And, while Brainard brought up some valid points about the new e-reader technologies, he missed the boat in terms of the content that is best suited for mobile devices. Here's the comment that I left on the CJR.org website: 
No, e-readers won't save journalism -- at least not the kind that the  author and the Columbia Journalism Review practice.

Consider the people reading this essay. What percentage of readers are consuming it on an e-reader, iPod, iPad, Android phone, or any other mobile device, relative to the percentage of readers who are looking at it on a PC or laptop screen? I suspect the mobile:PC ratio is quite small -- maybe just a few percentage points, if that (perhaps the CJR can let us know?). I further believe that even among those who are looking at it on a mobile device or e-reader, very few are reading it from start to finish. Like many publishers, the Columbia Journalism Review is still oriented toward long prose pieces that are a poor fit for mobile devices or the people who own them. Who is going to read a 4,546-word analysis (the length of this essay) on a small screen, or even a 1,000-word news article. How many would be willing to shell out subscription fees for long-form Time, Wired, or WaPo print content on a Nook or iPhone?

Even short-form content may be a stretch, when there are so many other free and low-cost distractions available on mobile devices. Publishers no longer have a monopoly on information or entertainment, like they did a decade ago, when tabloids, metro newspapers, books, magazines and CD walkmans were the staple on subway cars. Now when I look around at my fellow commuters, I see people playing games, listening to mp3s, texting, watching videos, checking Facebook for updates, and sometimes even looking at a newspaper or mobile news app. If people don't want to read a 2,000-word feature, or don't feel like paying for news (print or mobile), they still have too many free/cheaper options to choose from -- options that they didn't have before, because the technology wasn't widely available.
This last point about competition deserves a little additional commentary. I've been thinking a lot about the competitive environment for online news. Publishers assume people want news, when in actuality many of them just want information. Increasingly, it's not so important where that information comes from.

Consider product news. In the mid-1990s, when a new Apple product came out, the channels for information were far more restricted. People depended on the news media (and advertising) to find out about these products, because the only other channels were word-of-mouth and retail outlets. I don't need to pay to learn about the iPhone 4 from the New York Times' David Pogue (or, for that matter, and other news publisher), when I can get facts about the product from Apple.com, video from YouTube, and numerous opinions from blogs, message boards, and my online networks -- all for free. What extra value is Pogue delivering? Certainly, he's a great writer and is accurate and unbiased (well, most of the time), but is he worth $1 in print or a $n monthly subscription? I don't think so.  Neither will most other people, when they are prompted to pay online or on their iPad.



Sources and research: Columbia Journalism Review, New York Times/Bits, EdibleApple.com, Mediagazer

Image: New York Times iPhone app on the iPod touch. Creative Commons Generic License 2.0 -- you are free to use it for commercial or noncommercial work, as long as you credit the source (Ian Lamont) and link back to this blog post.

Related online/mobile commentary from Ian Lamont:

Monday, July 5, 2010

Dabba phones: A mobile business model for the developing world?

Interesting piece on the PBS Newshour tonight about a South African entrepreneur named Rael Lissoos bringing a low-cost phone and Internet access model to the poor in his country, mainly by buying telecom traffic in bulk and reselling it at a much lower rate than the South African carriers like Vodacom. The video below is missing a few important elements, such as precise costs for Dabba phone cards and phone services, but it seems to be a much more attractive option than the prices charged to local residents under the existing carrier regime -- $8 for a 20-minute cell-to-cell call? That's even worse than AT&T's prepaid phone rate in the U.S., which would be about $5 for a 20-minute call (I know, because I own a GoPhone, which uses prepaid rates of 25 cents per minute).

In any case, you can see what's going on in the video below. If that model can be profitably extended to other parts of Africa at rates which ordinary people can afford, the potential impact on commerce, health, government services, family bonds and other aspects of society will be incredible. I heard from a classmate at Sloan who helped bring similar cellphone service to remote areas of Pakistan earlier in his career that some of the people in these regions -- mostly illiterate and without electricity or any modern means of communicating outside of their villages -- were overjoyed at the introduction of basic cellphone service. We take mobile phones for granted, but for people who live way off the grid in desperately poor conditions, it was a transformative technology that made life measurably better.

Wednesday, May 19, 2010

Webkinz on the iPad? Apple says "no," thanks to Flash

My kids like Webkinz World, Ganz's kids-oriented virtual world that is based on the purchase of real-world stuffed toys. During a visit to my parents this morning, they said they wanted to play it on their older model Mac mini, and I was concerned it might not work (Webkinz technical problems have been problematic for us in the past).

But then it occurred to me: If it were an iPad, there would be no hope of Webkinz working at all. It requires Flash, which Steve Jobs does not want to see on his mobile devices, including the iPad, iPhone, and iPod touch.

That's excluding a lot of people. One estimate that I found a few months back puts the number of Webkinz users in the millions. And that made me wonder: What about all of the other kids-oriented sites that are out there? Is the iPad excluding these audiences as well?

I did a quick check on the Web. Club Penguin: Requires Flash Player 9. Games on Nick.com require Flash, too. I put the question out to Twitter about any other cases. @Atul asked about PBSkids.org. I checked. Sure enough, Curious George and many other games indeed require Flash to play.

The irony of Steve Jobs' anti-Flash mantra is that kids really do love the Apple's touch-enabled features. My kids love Cro-Mag, Bounce On, and Paper Toss on my iPod touch. I read with much interest this account from an EMC CTO, who describes his teenagers practically abandoning laptops and desktops for the iPad. Some kids-oriented brands (such as the SpongeBob franchise, which has Flash-only games on Nick.com) have branched out to the iPhone/iTouch /iPad platform with dedicated apps.

Is there any hope for Webkinz ever making it to the iPad? While the Apple-approved iPad app Cloud Browse allows a workaround, it is an imperfect and potentially risky solution.  

It's pretty clear that Jobs wants all rich Web applications to retool themselves to a new world order, in which sites conform to official Web standards or conform to the App Store standards dictated by Apple Inc. For companies like Ganz that have invested years in building up a complex suite of Flash-based games that play on most desktop PCs, neither option may be possible (does HTML 5 even support the sort of artwork and UIs that Ganz has for Webkinz?), or palatable, owing to the raw costs and rearchitecting that would be required. That's unfortunate for everyone involved -- Jobs, Ganz, and an audience of mostly young kids numbering in the tens of millions.

Or is it? This is exactly the sort of situation that could lead to an opportunity for a tablet maker or software partner that recognizes a compelling niche opportunity in an area which Apple doesn't want to play.

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

Mobile marketing, meet mobile reality


Everyone has seen those expensive smartphone commercials that show devices playing crisp videos, slick UI transitions, and smooth touchscreen functionality. And nearly everyone knows that the devices almost never perform as advertised.

One owner of a Nokia N97 decided to do something about it, and created a short YouTube video that shows Nokia's marketing fantasy contrasted with his own painful experience using the N97 interface and browsing the Web (turn down your computer's volume before hitting play):


It's not just the UI, either. The last 30 seconds of the video list some major functionality problems this owner has experienced. 


The N97 is now old news but the advertising for newer phones still relies on simulations, rather than the actual experience users will see. Caveat mobilius emptor!

Sources and research: Mobile Inc, Hacker News

Friday, July 3, 2009

Why user interface is important


I just read a great quote by David Pogue in his New York Times review of a D-Link home router/backup storage device:
Isn’t it amazing that, after all these years, it still hasn’t dawned on companies like D-Link that simplicity sells? They still don’t get it: spending a little money up front —on hardware design, streamlined software, better manuals -- would save a fortune in tech-support calls and store returns. ...

... In short, D-Link has gone to the considerable expense of inventing, designing and marketing a smart machine that could save a lot of people a lot of cost and complexity — and then hobbled it by making it much too cryptic and technical for 90 percent of its potential audience.
This reminded me of an incident earlier in the week when a relative came to me with his nearly brand-new BlackBerry Curve 8900 and complained that he couldn't get back to the old home menu. When I looked at the home screen, sure enough it had changed to about 40 minuscule icons on a pure white background, instead of the carrier home page, which has a blue graphic and five icons showing the most-used features. He had accidentally changed the home screen some days before and had tried every conceivable way to switch it back. Tech support at work wasn't helpful -- while they support email on the device, they don't handle anything else, because he bought it on his own. He called his employer's CIO, who was sympathetic, but could only advise him to call the carrier tech support. They told him to change the setting in the options screen, but he couldn't find that.

So I gave it a shot. The interface designed by Research in Motion is maddeningly complicated -- many options are only available from specific applications, or are buried in submenus. Changing options often requires multiple clicks to select the menu item, change to another setting, and then saving that setting. I hunted around in various places, including the most obvious place -- the home page icon for display/keyboard -- but could not find what I was looking for. I told him his best option was to go to AT&T store where he had bought the device and have them find the option, but he was afraid they would shrug or be unable to help him.

So I gave it one more try. And lo and behold, one of the last icons on the home menu was labeled "options" (separate from display/keyboard). I found the setting and changed it. He was overjoyed.

But it made me wonder. The BlackBerry UI is so unintuitive that it took five people -- including the CIO of a large organization -- to diagnose what was wrong. We collectively spent an hour or two on the issue.

And he's not the only one. I remember when I got my first BlackBerry several years ago. It was simply placed on my desk by someone in IT without any tutorial or manual. I'm a pretty tech-savvy individual, but I couldn't figure out how to turn it off -- I had to ask another user how to do it. Ditto for changing the phone volume or the position of icons on the screen -- I had to Google the solutions.

If even 10% of BlackBerry owners have similar problems, that represents a lot of frustration and millions of wasted hours every year. Research in Motion surely knows about these problems (the first BlackBerry came out eight or nine years ago) yet it is still shipping products that confound users with their complexity.

Besides D-Link and RIM, what other technology companies (or specific products) can't get a handle on the user experience?

(Update: Since writing this post, I have launched a company which is dedicated to helping people understand complicated technologies and concepts. Besides creating online posts which address questions such as What Is Google Drive, I have also published a series of guides under the In 30 Minutes brand.)